DE

Partnerships

Partnership or franchise: which route to growth suits you

Your own branches, franchising, licensing, a partnership or a joint venture: a decision guide for business owners who want to grow their concept, with a comparison table and checklist questions.

6 min read

Plans for redesigning a hotel terrace on a tableAI generated

Business is going well, customers are coming from further and further afield, and more and more often someone asks whether there could be something like this in the next town too. At that point, if not before, the question arises of how the company should grow. A second branch of your own, a franchise system, a licence for your brand or product, a partnership with another business or a jointly owned company for a new market: each route follows its own logic. This article sets the options side by side and helps you find the one that suits your business.

Five routes to growth

Our article on the differences between franchising, licensing and partnerships explains the basic terms in detail. For the growth decision, a brief overview from the perspective of a business owner who wants to expand is enough here.

  • Your own branches: full control over quality and presentation, but capital, staff and risk rest with the company alone.
  • Franchising: growth with the capital and commitment of independent partners. This requires a franchise head office that trains and supports them, binding system standards and careful pre-contractual disclosure. The partners pay ongoing fees, known as the royalty.
  • Licensing: a brand or product is made available to another company for its use. This is comparatively quick but offers little control over how the licensee runs its business.
  • Partnership: the partners remain independent and work together on joint projects. The ties are looser, and so is the degree of standardisation.
  • Joint venture (a jointly owned company): two or more companies set up a joint company, usually for a specific market or a specific project.

The criteria for your decision

Which route suits you depends less on preference than on a few sober criteria. The maturity of the concept comes first: has the business been tested over a long period, are the processes written down, does it work even without the founder at the till? Closely linked to this is transferability. Something that thrives in one place mainly because of the owner’s personality is harder to replicate than a clearly described process.

Next come capital and speed. Your own branches tie up your own money and grow only as fast as the company can invest. Franchising and licensing use other people’s capital and can therefore expand more quickly. Control over quality runs in the opposite direction: it is greatest with your own branches and smallest with licensing. Franchising sits in between, because standards and support safeguard quality without the head office running every business itself.

Finally, the effort of supporting partners, the risk and the exit all count. A franchise system demands ongoing training, support and development; the head office is a business in its own right with its own tasks. A partnership is comparatively easy to end, whereas a franchise network or a joint company is not. Anyone deciding today should therefore also ask what a way back would look like.

The routes compared

CriterionOwn branchesFranchiseLicencePartnershipJoint venture
Control over qualityvery highhigh through standardslowlow to mediumshared
Own capitalhighmedium, mainly for the head officelowlowshared
Speedrather slowmedium to fastfastfastmedium
Support effortmanaging your own teamshigh and ongoinglowlow to mediummedium
Standardisationhighhighlowlowdepends on the project
Commitmentcompletelong contractslimited by contractlooseclose
Exitsale or closurecomplexas per contractcomparatively simplecomplex

A rough guide only. In each case, a great deal depends on how the contracts are drafted.

The table shows a basic pattern: the more control a route offers, the more capital and management it demands from the company itself. The easier the entry, the looser your influence usually is over what reaches the customer. There is no route without trade-offs, but there is one that fits your own situation.

Two typical starting points

Two generalised cases show how different the answer can be. A restaurant thrives on the signature of its head chef, on its regulars and on its location by the harbour. Here, a lot speaks for a partnership, with a hotel or a delicatessen for instance, or for a second address of its own that is closely managed. A service provider, on the other hand, that has written down its processes from the first meeting to the invoice and can train new staff in a few weeks is well placed to take on a pilot partner. What matters is not the sector but how much of the success lies in the concept and how much in the person who runs it today.

The step-by-step route: from partnership to franchise system

Many business owners do not have to commit to the big step straight away. An obvious route leads forward in stages:

  1. Partnership: a partner business takes on individual services or offers the concept on a small scale. Both learn what can be transferred and what cannot.
  2. Pilot partner: an independent partner runs a business according to the concept, with close support and processes recorded in writing. This shows whether the model works without the founder.
  3. Franchise system: only once the manual, training, standards and profitability have been tested do you set up a franchise head office and look for further partners.

The advantage of this route is that each stage delivers insights before bigger commitments arise. Our article on franchise readiness and pilot operations describes how to test whether a concept is ready to become a system.

Each stage delivers insights before bigger commitments arise.

What to watch out for

Franchising is not a tool for spreading an unfinished concept quickly. Partners invest their own money and trust that the system works, which is why pre-contractual disclosure demands care and honesty. Conversely, some business owners underestimate what a partnership can achieve: for a concept that depends heavily on one place or one person, it is often the more honest and more relaxed route.

Partnerships with competitors and jointly owned companies raise additional questions of competition and company law; you will find more on this in our article on the cooperation agreement. Whichever route you choose, have experts review the contracts and structure, such as a law firm experienced in franchise and distribution law, before the first partners sign.

Questions for a self-assessment

Before you commit, take an honest look at your own company and your role in it. The following questions will help:

  • Does the business also work on days when you are not there?
  • Are the key processes written down clearly enough for an outsider to follow them?
  • How much of your own capital and how much time can you put into growth?
  • How important is it to you to control every detail the customer experiences?
  • Do you want to lead and support people, or would you rather work with equal partners?
  • What would an exit look like if the route you chose turned out to be wrong?

Frequently asked questions

When is a franchise system worthwhile?

When the concept has been tested, can be transferred to other locations and people, and its processes are written down. A pilot business with an independent partner shows whether that is the case. There are no fixed timeframes for this.

What is the practical difference between a licence and a franchise?

With a licence, you mainly grant the use of a brand or product, and the licensee runs its business largely as it sees fit. With a franchise, you pass on an entire business model with standards, training and ongoing support, and you have more influence over quality.

Can a partnership later become a franchise?

Yes, that is an obvious step-by-step route. The partnership shows what can be transferred, a pilot partner tests the model, and the setting up of a system can follow. The contracts are then redrafted.

When does a joint venture make sense?

When two companies want to develop a specific market or project together and share capital, knowledge and responsibility to do so. The ties are close, so goals, shares and the exit should be clearly settled from the outset.

This article is for general information and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Laws and funding programmes can change; discuss your own situation with a specialist lawyer, tax adviser or your bank.

Read on in our network

Read next

Business owners recommend business owners

Which business would you hire again at any time?

Tell us in three sentences how you know them, what you worked on together and who you would recommend them to. We check every recommendation before it is published.

Recommend a business Become a franchisee