DE

Referral marketing

Disclosing paid recommendations: commission, stakes and the law

A commission, a discount or a stake in a company is no stain, as long as it is disclosed. Which rules apply to paid recommendations and reviews, and what a clear note looks like.

6 min read

Handshake over a table with coffee cupsAI generated

A bathroom renovator has worked with a tile dealer for years and regularly sends customers his way. Recently, the dealer began paying a commission for every job referred. That changes nothing about the quality of the recommendation, as the renovator is convinced by the tiles and the advice. Even so, he asks himself a legitimate question: does he have to tell his customers that he earns money from the recommendation? The short answer is yes, he should. This article explains why, and how to do it without much effort.

The principle: the commercial purpose must be recognisable

German unfair competition law sets a clear framework here. Under Section 5a(4) of the German Act against Unfair Competition (UWG), anyone who fails to make clear the commercial purpose of a commercial practice acts unfairly, unless that purpose is immediately apparent from the circumstances. A recommendation for which the recommender receives something pursues a business interest alongside the good advice. The recipient must be able to recognise that interest.

The idea behind it is simple: anyone reading a recommendation generally assumes that it is made out of conviction. If something is given in return, that changes how the recommendation should be judged, even if it is honestly meant. Openness takes nothing away from the recipient. It gives them the information they need to reach a well-founded decision of their own.

Which benefits you should disclose

Anyone who receives something for a recommendation, or who is connected to the recommended company in a particular way, should disclose it. Typical cases are:

  • a commission for every job or customer referred
  • a discount on your own purchases from the recommended company
  • a gift or something else in return, such as an invitation or a free service
  • a stake in the recommended company, even a small one
  • a close personal connection, such as being related to the owner

If in doubt, one simple question helps: what would a reader want to know in order to judge the recommendation correctly? That is exactly what belongs in the note.

What a clear note looks like

A good note sits directly beside the recommendation, not in the general terms and conditions and not at the bottom of a long page. It is short, easy to understand and states the nature of the connection. Some sample wordings:

SituationPossible note beside the recommendation
Stake in the company“The recommender holds a stake in the company.”
Commission for referred jobs“The recommender receives a commission for referred jobs.”
Discount or gift“The recommender has received a benefit from the company.”
Family relationship“The recommender is related to the owner.”
Reward from a referral programme“The recommender receives a reward for this recommendation.”

These wordings are examples and are no substitute for checking the individual case.

A note that the reader does not understand fails in its purpose. So write it in plain words and in the same language as the recommendation itself.

An open note costs one sentence and protects the trust on which every recommendation rests.

Openness in conversation, too

The question of disclosure does not only concern websites and brochures. Anyone who recommends a partner business to a customer in conversation and receives a commission for doing so should mention it as well. A passing remark is enough: that the partner pays a commission for referred jobs and that the recommendation is nevertheless made out of conviction. Such openness shows customers that nothing is being hidden, and it tends to strengthen trust rather than weaken it.

Reviews: authenticity is a must

Besides recommendations, reviews play a major role, and here too there are clear rules. Under Section 5b(3) UWG, anyone who makes consumer reviews accessible must state whether and how they ensure that the reviews come from consumers who have actually used the goods or services. This applies to businesses that display customer testimonials on their own website just as much as to portals.

Fake reviews are always prohibited, and so is commissioning fake reviews from third parties. This follows from the annex to Section 3(3) UWG, points 23b and 23c. For business owners, this means asking genuine customers for honest feedback and steering clear of any form of bought stars. A smaller number of genuine voices carries further than a long list that nobody trusts.

Referral programmes: permitted if transparent

Many businesses reward customers who bring in new customers, for example with a credit note or a small gift. Such referral programmes are permitted if they are transparent. The new customer should be able to see that the recommender receives a reward for the tip. Also set out the conditions in writing: what the reward is for, when it becomes due and whether the new customer receives a benefit too. Clear rules avoid misunderstandings on both sides.

One stumbling block lies in making contact. Promotional e-mails to people who have been recommended require their consent (Section 7 UWG). A satisfied customer passing on an acquaintance’s address does not replace that consent. It is therefore better to have the contact made in person: the customer speaks to their acquaintance directly, and anyone who is interested gets in touch of their own accord.

Data protection: third-party data need a legal basis

Closely linked to this is data protection. The names, phone numbers or e-mail addresses of third parties may only be passed on and used if there is a legal basis for doing so, often the consent of the person concerned. A form into which customers simply enter their acquaintances’ contact details is therefore not a good idea. Here too, a personal introduction by the recommender is the safe and usually the more effective route. And anyone who publishes a recommendation with the recommender’s name and company also needs a legal basis for that, as a rule the recommender’s consent.

Spain: comparable rules from EU law

If you do business on Mallorca, on the Costa del Sol or elsewhere in Spain, you will find comparable rules there. They are based on common EU law, above all the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, as amended by Directive (EU) 2019/2161. The principles are the same: the commercial background of a recommendation must be recognisable, and reviews must be genuine. Since rules and their interpretation can change, it is worth checking the current position before launching a referral programme.

How to recognise a reputable recommendation platform

Whether it is a magazine, a directory or a network, a reputable platform for recommendations follows a few clear principles. Recommendations are voluntary and are not bought. The recommender’s name and company are visible. Stakes and other connections are disclosed. And paid placements are recognisable as such, so that readers can distinguish between editorial selection and bought visibility. Checking these points quickly shows you which recommendations you can trust.

This overview explains the rules in general terms and is no substitute for legal advice. For designing a referral programme or for questions in an individual case, a specialist lawyer can help, for example one who specialises in intellectual property and competition law.

Frequently asked questions

Does even a small reward for a recommendation have to be mentioned?

Even small benefits can matter when judging a recommendation. A short note costs little and avoids any impression that the recommendation was bought. If in doubt, the note is the better choice.

May a business reward customers for recommendations?

Yes, referral programmes are permitted if they are transparent. The new customer should be able to see that the recommender receives a reward. Promotional e-mails to people who have been recommended require their consent.

What applies to customer testimonials on your own website?

Under Section 5b(3) of the German Act against Unfair Competition (UWG), anyone who makes consumer reviews accessible must state whether and how they ensure that the reviews come from consumers who have actually used the service. Fake or bought reviews are always prohibited.

Do different rules apply in Spain?

The rules are comparable because they are based on common EU law, above all the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive and Directive (EU) 2019/2161. For the details on the ground, expert advice is worthwhile.

This article is for general information and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Laws and funding programmes can change; discuss your own situation with a specialist lawyer, tax adviser or your bank.

Read on in our network

Read next

Business owners recommend business owners

Which business would you hire again at any time?

Tell us in three sentences how you know them, what you worked on together and who you would recommend them to. We check every recommendation before it is published.

Recommend a business Become a franchisee