DE

Understanding franchising

Franchise, licence or cooperation: how the business models differ

Franchise, licence, commercial agency, cooperation and branch network: we set the models side by side and show how they differ in capital, risk, control and commitment.

6 min read

A tradesman’s firm has developed a method for renovating bathrooms in just a few days. Customers love it, and colleagues from other cities are asking whether they can join in. Now the owner faces a fundamental question: should he license his know-how, build a franchise system, cooperate with friendly businesses or open locations of his own? Each of these models can be the right one. But they differ markedly in who puts in the capital, who carries the risk and how tightly the parties are bound to one another.

Franchise: the complete package

In a franchise, the partner receives not just a single right but a complete package: brand, know-how, system standards and ongoing support from head office. In return, the partner accepts the right of head office to issue instructions within the scope of the agreement, for example on quality, design and processes, and pays ongoing fees. The partner remains independent and invests their own money. Our article on how franchising works describes how this plays out day to day; here the focus is on how it differs from the other models.

Licence: a right without a business concept

A licence permits the use of a brand, a patent or a technology in return for a licence fee. The licensee may, for example, apply a protected process or make products under a well-known name. What is usually missing is everything around it: as a rule there is no complete business concept, no manual for daily operations and no ongoing support. The licensee largely shapes the business on their own.

For the licensor, the model is lean, because there is no need to build a head office with training and advice. In return, the licensor has less influence over how the brand or technology appears on the market. For the licensee, a licence means more freedom, but also less backing when something goes wrong in the business.

Authorised dealers and commercial agents: sales with different roles

Authorised dealers buy a manufacturer’s goods and resell them in their own name and for their own account, often with a fixed territory and certain sales obligations. A complete business concept of the kind found in franchising is usually not part of the deal.

The commercial agent works differently. Agents broker deals in someone else’s name, that is, for the company they represent, and receive a commission for doing so. Their rights and duties are set out in Sections 84 et seq. of the German Commercial Code (HGB). Particularly important is the compensation claim under Section 89b HGB: when the contract ends, the agent can, under certain conditions, demand compensation for the customer base they have built up and from which the company continues to benefit. Whether comparable claims are also open to authorised dealers or franchisees depends on how the individual contract is drafted.

Cooperation: equal partners with a shared goal

In a cooperation, independent companies work together on an equal footing to achieve a common purpose. There is no head office setting a concept, but partners meeting as equals. Typical forms are:

  • Purchasing group: Several businesses pool their volumes and negotiate better terms together.
  • Joint offer: A hotel, a restaurant and a boat hire firm put together a package for their guests.
  • Joint venture: Two or more companies jointly set up a new company for a particular project.

Cooperations are flexible and can often be started quickly. But they require clear agreements on who contributes what and how earnings are shared, because without a head office there is nobody to make the call when in doubt.

Branch network: everything in your own hands

In a branch network, a company opens its own locations and staffs them with employees. Head office raises all the capital, carries all the risk and has full control. That secures uniformity but slows growth, because every new location has to be financed and managed from the company’s own resources.

The models compared side by side

The overview below compares the models by the features that usually tip the balance when choosing. The entries describe typical characteristics; an individual contract may differ.

ModelCapital and riskControlGrowthCommitmentCosts for the partner
Franchisewith the partnerhigh, through standards and contractual rights to issue instructionsfast, with the capital of many partnersclose, usually for several yearsentry fee and ongoing fees
Licencewith the licenseelow, limited to the licensed rightfast, but with little steeringtied to the right of uselicence fee
Commercial agentmainly with the company representedmedium, brokering in someone else’s namedepends on the number of agentscontractual, compensation claim possibleno fee, the agent earns commission
Cooperationwith all partiesjointly agreedflexible, depending on the projectloose to closeshare of the costs of the joint project
Branch networkwith head officecompleteslower, from own resourcesemployment contract of the managersnone, the managers are employees

Typical characteristics; in each case the contract decides.

What competition law says

Anyone concluding contracts between companies is also operating within competition law. Franchise agreements are vertical agreements, because head office and partners operate at different levels. In the EU they are governed by the Vertical Block Exemption Regulation (EU) 2022/720, which has applied since 1 June 2022 and runs until 31 May 2034. It exempts many common clauses from the ban on cartels but sets limits, for example on price stipulations or non-compete obligations. Our article on the franchise agreement explains which clauses are affected in practice.

Cooperations between competitors, by contrast, are horizontal agreements. They are subject to the ban on cartels under Section 1 of the German Act against Restraints of Competition (GWB) and Article 101 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU). Agreements on prices or on sharing out customers are in principle off limits there. For small and medium-sized enterprises, however, there is an important relief: the SME cartel exemption (Mittelstandskartell) under Section 3 GWB. It allows agreements that rationalise economic processes through cooperation between businesses, such as joint purchasing, provided that competition is not substantially impaired and the agreement improves the competitiveness of the small and medium-sized enterprises.

It is not the label that decides, but who puts in the capital, who carries the risk and who steers.

Which model suits you

Whether you want to pass on a concept or join a system, choosing a model is above all a question of how much control you want to exercise or accept. If you want to spread a proven concept quickly and consistently with many partners, franchising is the right choice. If you only want to make a right usable without building a head office, think of a licence. If you want to grow stronger together with like-minded businesses without giving up your independence, choose cooperation. And if you want to run every location yourself, stay with a branch network.

With hybrid forms in particular, it pays to seek the advice of a lawyer specialising in franchise law, because the label in the contract alone does not determine which rules apply. A contract called a “licence” can in substance be a franchise, and vice versa.

Frequently asked questions

Is every brand licence already a franchise?

No. A licence grants a single right, for example to a brand or a technology. The relationship only becomes a franchise once a business concept, documented know-how, standards and ongoing support are added.

Do franchisees have a compensation claim like commercial agents?

The compensation claim under Section 89b of the German Commercial Code (HGB) applies directly to commercial agents. Whether it can be applied by analogy to other sales partners depends on how the individual contract is drafted and should be checked by an expert.

Are competitors allowed to cooperate at all?

Yes, in many cases. What is prohibited are agreements that restrict competition, for example on prices. For small and medium-sized enterprises, the SME cartel exemption under Section 3 of the German Act against Restraints of Competition (GWB) makes it easier to cooperate in ways that improve their competitiveness.

Can a cooperation later become a franchise system?

That is possible, for example if one business develops the joint concept further and opens it up to others. Roles, contracts and obligations then change fundamentally, however, and all parties should discuss this openly.

This article is for general information and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Laws and funding programmes can change; discuss your own situation with a specialist lawyer, tax adviser or your bank.

Read on in our network

  • maidavBusiness, finance, future

    There you will find articles on business management, finance and the future of companies that want to grow.

  • MiliniaMoney and markets

    There you can read about money and markets and the economic data that offer guidance when choosing a business model.

Read next

Business owners recommend business owners

Which business would you hire again at any time?

Tell us in three sentences how you know them, what you worked on together and who you would recommend them to. We check every recommendation before it is published.

Recommend a business Become a franchisee